Market News

Former Sugar Mama’s Bakery Space in Downtown Bloomington Leased to Bayleaf & Butterscotch

BLOOMINGTON, IL — AXIS 360 Commercial Real Estate Specialists is pleased to announce the successful leasing of the former Sugar Mama’s bakery space at 115 W. Jefferson St., Suite 105, in Downtown Bloomington to Bayleaf & Butterscotch, a thoughtfully curated coffee shop and bakery concept known for high-quality beverages, fresh baked goods, and a warm neighborhood atmosphere.

Bayleaf & Butterscotch currently operates in Pleasant Plains, Illinois, where the business has quickly built a loyal following since opening in June 2025. Despite being located in a community of approximately 800 residents, Bayleaf & Butterscotch has drawn customers from surrounding areas, including Springfield, while also participating in farmers markets and local community events.

The new Downtown Bloomington location will offer specialty coffee and espresso beverages, fresh pastries and desserts prepared onsite, light breakfast and lunch offerings, and seasonal menu items inspired by local tastes. The shop is expected to create a welcoming environment for downtown residents, professionals, visitors, and customers looking for a premium yet approachable café experience.

“Bayleaf & Butterscotch is exactly the type of locally rooted, experience-driven business that adds energy and foot traffic to Downtown Bloomington,” said Meghan O’Neal-Rogozinski of AXIS 360 Commercial Real Estate Specialists. “This lease represents another positive step for the downtown retail corridor and brings a fresh concept into a space that already has a strong bakery tradition.”

The addition of Bayleaf & Butterscotch is expected to complement surrounding businesses and contribute to the continued growth of Downtown Bloomington as a destination for dining, shopping, meetings, and community gathering.

The lease was facilitated by Meghan O’Neal-Rogozinski, CCIM of AXIS 360 Commercial Real Estate Specialists, a Bloomington-Normal commercial real estate brokerage firm focused on helping businesses, investors, and property owners make strategic real estate decisions throughout Central Illinois.

About Bayleaf & Butterscotch

Bayleaf & Butterscotch is a coffee shop and bakery concept offering specialty coffee, espresso beverages, fresh baked goods, pastries, desserts, and light breakfast and lunch options. With roots in Pleasant Plains, Illinois, the business emphasizes high-quality products, thoughtful hospitality, and a cozy café atmosphere.